The Samuel Pepys of the OSS...
Birthday boy Zendexor at 72 in front of the even older Lancaster Castle with an incongruously modern van to the right2026 May 24th:
NOTES ON THE CHRONOLOGY OF BRADBURY'S MARS
From researcher Lone Wolf:
...I came across a story by entitled “Dwellers in Silence” [Planet Stories, Spring 1949], which turned out to be
the first publication of the story later included in The Martian
Chronicles under the title “The Long Years”.
One curious fact is the difference of the dates in it. In The
Martian Chronicles (1950 edition) this story is dated “April
2026” (i.e. it should have happened last month in that particular
time-line!). But in Dwellers in Silence it appears to be in 2017 (which can be
derived from the mention that it is 20 years after 1997, when
according to the text the Great War on Earth and the plague on Mars
have happened).
Thus if we assume the same relative chronology of the
dates of the stories like that in the book, the first expeditions to
Mars should have been in the years 1989 – 1991, although I doubt
that this story was originally meant to be part of some continuity –
we can see for instance that here the captain of the Earth ship is
called Parsons and not Wilder from the Fourth Expedition, as it is in
the book version (and anyway, I've always thought that the chronology
set up for the book is a little too short – all the events of the
four expeditions, the mass colonization of the planet and then the
return to Earth when the war starts happen, in less than one
decade!).
But somehow those old dates feel more relevant to me, even
if we think them to belong to some alternative time-line – all
Bradbury's Martian stories have some old-time vibe and I can't
imagine them happening in our era or even in our future (and as I
learnt from the article in Wikipaedia, all the dates in the book in
the later editions from 1990s on have been moved 31 years ahead, so
now the whole sequence starts from 2030). Here are excerpts from
the two versions for comparison:
It
was the twentieth year after the Great War. Mars was a tomb planet.
Whether or not Earth was the same was a matter for much silent debate
for himself, or his family, on the long Martian nights.
(…)
“The
four crosses were there, sir. The names were still on them. I wrote
them down to be sure.” He produced a white paper and read from it.
“Alice Hathaway, Marguerite, Susan and John Hathaway. All four died
of the plague in July, 1997.”
“Thank
you, Williamson,” said Parsons. He closed his eyes.
“Twenty
years ago, sir,” said Williamson, his hands trembling. He was
afraid to look up at the people at the table.
“Yes,
twenty years ago,” said Parsons.
(Dwellers in Silence)
It
was the twentieth year after the Great War. Mars was a tomb planet.
Whether or not Earth was the same was a matter for much silent debate
for Hathaway and his family on the long nights.
(…)
"The
four crosses were there, sir. The names were still on them. I wrote
them down to be sure." He read from a white paper: "Alice,
Marguerite, Susan, and John Hathaway. Died of unknown virus. July
2007."
"Thank
you, Williamson." Wilder closed his eyes.
"Nineteen
years ago, sir," Williamson's hand trembled.
"Yes."
(The Martian Chronicles, 1950 edition: April 2026, "The Long Years"
(or in the 1997 edition: April 2057))
Comment from Zendexor: Bradbury, to me, stands on the verge of the mainstream OSS, not because of his subject-matter (which is absolutely central) but because of his ultra-distinctive style, which creates the vibe that LW mentions. His prose has the most pronounced dream-like effect of any writer, at any rate when he is focusing on Mars. Consequently it's just as well that he did put some dates in, to help anchor his tales in a sense of reality, in whatever continuum and timeline they may be. Calendar dates, though they do have a romance in themselves, are also blunt numbers; and Bradbury's hallucinatory yarns benefit from that injection of bluntness.
2026 May 15th:
JOHN CARTER AND BARSOOM - MORE ABOUT THE MYSTERY
The debate has continued in further emails since those which I quoted in Telemorphs and Gustavus Pope.
What follows contains, in particular, one idea that struck me as tremendous, and I have emphasized it thus.
LW, 13th May:
...I was musing recently about Burroughs and his uncanny
ability to describe improbable worlds and events without any
explanations and still make it sound credible. Thus he never explains
the origin of John Carter and the reason for his immortality (and one
should think he would have a lot of memories about his life on Earth
before going to Barsoom, but somehow this topic never comes up after
the first novel). Maybe (and I am not sure here if this is my
original idea or I've read it somewhere – I really can't remember,
but I have the feeling that I've seen something similar in some
online discussion) the author has intended that Carter turns out later to
be originally from Mars – from that ancient extinct race of the
white Martians who build the great cities in the time where there were
still seas on the planet. Maybe they had sent an expedition
which crashed on Earth and John Carter was the only survivor, who got
amnesia from the shock, but later adapted to the life on the planet.
There are in fact a lot of allusions in the text which seem as if intended to prepare
the reader for such a revelation: for instance, he is often compared to
the ancient white Martian race, he never misses an opportunity to
emphasize
his particular attraction to Mars and no other planet, etc. But the
moment never comes. I think Burroughs probably had some vague idea to
use this later – maybe to make John Carter remember his true
identity and use his ancient knowledge in order to save the planet –
but he never came to that; either he decided against it for some reason,
or simply forgot. He seems to be one of those writers who invent
the story in the process of telling it and have only a vague notion
about what will happen in the end. Thus he often concentrates on what
I call “side adventures” – secondary plots in which the
protagonist becomes involved while being deviated from some major
quest (I
actually find this rather annoying, because I wait for the story to
return to the main theme, which often doesn't happen, but the “side
adventure” becomes instead the main content of the particular
book). Thus he wrote a lot of sequels or spin-offs of his sagas (the
Martian, the Venusian, etc.), but never reached any real conclusion.
In the case of the Barsoom cycle it is never explained how the main
problem – containing the overpopulation of a small dying planet
with limited resources by a virtually immortal species – was
resolved when John Carter became supreme warlord and established
world peace. Before there were the quasi-feudal civilization of
constantly warring city-states and the suicidal cult of Issus which
maintained the control over the population, but he removed all that.
Maybe it was exactly here where his ancient knowledge from the
long-forgotten era of the white Martians should have come in play
(because they somehow managed to live on Barsoom once and even to
create a higher civilization), but perhaps Burroughs himself couldn't
come up with any solution to use in his fiction and that's why
he kept postponing the conclusion of the story, and thus now we'll
never now how it was originally meant to be...
As
for that book of J. J.Astor, I remember now that I also came
across it, but I found it almost unreadable and later completely forgot it... If I am not mistaken though, there was the
interesting detail that Astor was using the same term “apergy”
for the repulsive anti-gravitational force as in Across the
Zodiac by Percy Greg. Previously I'd always thought that the idea
of anti-gravitation was rather modern (from the post-rocket era's SF)
and I was surprised to find it as
early as the 19th century.
Z, 14th May:
The idea that Carter was originally a Barsoomian
is brilliant! Much better than my own theory that he was an Atlantean.
I find it easy enough to adjust to the idea that the ancient seafaring
Martians, who didn't invent flyers, nevertheless despatched one
expedition to Jasoom - since Barsoom is full of mavericks and lone
inventors; in fact all the inventors and savants seem to be loners - Ras
Thavas, Fal Sivas, Phor Tak... (No think-tanks or research institutes
on Barsoom. It's not their style.)
I
would dispute the idea that Carter as Warlord brought peace to
Barsoom. The evidence of the series contradicts that. He seems to have
created a fairly solid alliance of the sanest or most powerful states -
Helium, Ptarth, Kaol, Duhor - by the series' end. But the red
Martians are too bellicose for world peace, and Carter himself is so
fond of a scrap, it would only take one princess-kidnapping to set him
off...
However,
the final story brings a threat from Sassoom, which maybe, just maybe,
might get the red men to sink their differences for a while. Who
knows. If only one could get ERB to finish his work via Ouija bord.
I
doubt whether anyone else other than ERB could finish the series. No
other writer can convincingly combine his qualities of ramshackle
semi-consistency and the sort of lanky, beguiling sentence-structure
which I've not met in any other writer.
Having
said all this, the idea that Carter was a Barsoomian doesn't dispense
with the need for parallel evolutions, since we still have Ulysses
Paxton's marriage to Valla Dia - for which they both need to be human.
LW, 15 May 2026:
In this regard I've been
wondering about Ulysses Paxton too – did he also become immortal?
But that is not clear from the books. And John Carter didn't become
immortal when he came to Barsoom, but he was such from the start (he
says that he doesn't remember any youth or beginning of his life on
Earth, although Burroughs never returns to this topic and leaves it
without explanation). At first I thought that maybe this was some
effect from his living on Mars and thus becoming like the Martians or
that it was an inherent quality of his astral double in which he goes
there, but it doesn't seem likely that all Martians live in astral
bodies too – they appear material enough and they doesn't
astral-project themselves between planets, only John Carter does so
and this only between Earth and Mars, being attracted particularly to
the latter probably only because he once came from there, and back
because his original body still remains on Earth (it can
be argued, of course, that he is strong as an Earthman and so able to
do his miraculous jumps and stunts on Mars, but maybe that's because
he has developed stronger muscles while adapting himself to the
stronger terrestrial gravity during his age-long life on the
planet). And then Burroughs doesn't seem to understand this astral
body as composed of some subtle matter, as do the theosophists and
other occult writers, but something more like those doppelgangers
which great mystics and yogis are believed to be able to
produce as if “copying” themselves, permitting them to be in
many places simultaneously. Which leads me to another thought – could Barsoom actually exist in a slightly different phase of
reality, where the doppelganger also appears? (and I don't mean here the
“astral plane” of the occultists, but a different aspect of the
same reality, maybe even one of many which intersect in the same
planet – something like the parallel world of Thomahlia in the
novel The Blind Spot of Homer Eon Flindt, which is still Earth,
but corresponding to another section of the ether vibrational
spectrum).
This can be another ontological justification of the OSS – that we do not perceive directly the external world, but
only its re-presentation, which is a reconstruction made by our brain
on the base of the impressions, received by our sensory apparatus,
filtered through our cultural paradigm, thus being only a small
section even of the abstraction made by our senses. Then maybe the
higher principles of our organism (like soul, spirit, etc.) have
access to the total reality, but we perceive in our consciousness
only that phase (or section of it) to which our mind is culturally
tuned and thus currently we “see” the other planets through the
“eyes” of our probes. These are machines made of dead non-organic
matter. Even if they are controlled by advanced software, they are
still not complex enough to be able to harbour higher principles (or
“souls” of their own), and so, being naturally tuned to the “dead”
phase of reality and interacting only with that, they show us dead
worlds. But the astronomers of the previous ages even with their much
less perfect equipment were living persons and thus perhaps able to
glimpse sometimes into the other phases, and maybe this is how such
“illusions” appeared like the canals on Mars as seen by Lowell
and other observers or the surface of Venus with its two circumpolar
continents and seven equatorial seas between them as mapped by
Bianchini.
Z, 15th May:
That
is a another huge idea I had not thought of - that we see only that
version of the Solar System to which we are culturally attuned. It has
immense possibilities. For example, one might imagine a campaign to
readjust the attunement, so as to create or re-create the Solar System
one wants to have!
By
the way, regarding John Carter's travels between Earth and Barsoom:
Richard A Lupoff in his critical study of Barsoom theorizes that the
astral journeys are between one continuum and another; thus, if a native
Barsoomian were to try the trip in reverse in the same way, he wouldn't
reach our Earth - instead he'd reach Jasoom, which is Earth's aspect in a different
continuum. Similarly if the spaceship in The Moon Maid had succeeded
in reaching the fourth planet it would have found not Barsoom but simply
Mars. You can't reach across dimensions by spaceship: you can only do
it by doing what John Carter did - whatever that deed may have
entailed.
As
to whether Paxton becomes immortal: maybe there's indeed something in
the air of Barsoom that prevents Earth-style ageing. (For doubtless a
different reason to the anti-ageing effects of life in Pellucidar.) Of
course, even Barsoomians eventually age, if they survive long enough -
as did Ras Thavas, which is why he had to have his brain transplanted...
2026 May 13th:
REACHING OUT FOR STELLAR INFLUENCERS
Here's a suggested plot-brew:
Take the following ingredients:
- the weird "Douglas-Ouyang planets" in Cordwainer Smith's Under Old Earth;
- the idea of suns possessing consciousness in Olaf Stapledon's Star Maker;
Mix together to form the theme for a story in which the OSS is contacted remotely by exoplanet or exosolarian influencers, and then:
- add the following candidate influencer, for which I quote
from Sue French writing in the May 2008 issue of Sky & Telescope:
...the fascinating binary star W Ursae Majoris, just 162 light-years away. Its components are so close together that they're pulled into teardrop shapes that actually touch! Both stars are yellow dwarfs, one a bit larger than our Sun and the other a little smaller. The conjoined stars whirl madly around each other every 8 hours...
I'd
recommend, as in the Smith tale, that the influence be defeated; but,
on the way, there'd be room for fine shenanigans. An ideal motive, in
fact, for some maverick culture to create an off-the-beaten-track
mystery on an OSS world.
After all, just think for a moment about that crazy phenomenon: a pair of stars actually conjoined in a whirling cosmic dance! A Martian savant who tuned into that - well, I leave it to your imagination what he might do.
>> Tales Unwritten
2026 May 12th:
TELEMORPHS AND GUSTAVUS POPE
Had an exchange of emails with Lone Wolf this morning.
The starting point was my remark at the end of our notes to the latest Guess The World answer (see Steamy Seas and Saurians on Saturn): "Strange how these old writers didn't hesitate to use words for Terran species when describing life on other worlds."
LW responds:
If I remember correctly Gustavus W. Pope did the same thing while describing Mars and Venus in his two "Romances of the Planets", published in America around the same time (1894 and 1895). I remember also him describing some palace on Mars decorated with sculptures of classic mythologic figures like Nereids and Tritons with tridents riding seahorses etc. (not just similar figures named so metaphorically, but, as I understood, practically identical with their Terrestrial equivalents, which coincidence he was explaining as a result of parallel cultural developments). His samples of the Martian language were also taken from Sanskrit and ancient Greek in a curious mixture, but he doesn't mention this at all and his characters somehow never notice it. And it is not that he implies some common origin or interplanetary contacts in the past - Earthlings, Martians and "Plutonians" (as he calls the inhabitants of the destroyed asteroid progenitor planet) in his novels are humans that somehow evolved the same way on different worlds with only minor variations in skin colour and stature. And while it may be speculated that given the similar conditions on each planet the intelligent species would teleologically evolve along the same lines in more or less humanoid form, if this identity were to extend as far as repeating the same forms in their culture, arts and language, the universe would be a rather boring place (even only in our own planet we have more diversity than that).
My response:
Quite
so - it would indeed be boring. The ideal for me is Burroughs' and C S
Lewis' "telemorphs" - my term for independently-evolved humans on other
worlds - which are human but culturally original.
It should be
possible to invent some OSS-style pseudoscientific blah to explain the
biological similarity. For example: solar radiation, common to all System
worlds, might contain within it an unsuspected blueprint for parallel
evolution towards humanity (though not towards other organisms). As for
why it should work for humans alone and not (say) for elephants, well,
it may be something to do with a future community of intellects
influencing the past... blah, blah.
2026 May 7th:
SUB-MOONS: AN OVERLOOKED RESOURCE
Not a long entry, this, but something to mention in passing: it's rare, very rare, to find a tale that refers to a natural satellite of a satellite. I can only think of two examples.
One is the moon of Triton (if I remember correctly) that is mentioned in Piers Anthony's Macroscope (1969), which is not to any appreciable extent an OSS novel.
The other, earlier one is the moon of Callisto which is the scene for John Wyndham's definitely OSS tale Dumb Martian (Galaxy, July 1952): an unforgettable drama in which a slave gets the better of her master. The setting, isolated and grim, intensifies the tension between the two main characters.
...Jupiter IV/II was, by definition, a sub-moon, and probably a captured asteroid. The surface was not cratered, like Luna's: it was simply a waste of jagged, riven rocks. The satellite as a while had the form of an irregular ovoid; it was a bleak, cheerless lump of stone splintered off some vanished planet, with nothing whatever to commend it but its situation.
There have to be way-load stations...
That description would fit a current hard-sf narrative very well, with no OSS element whatsoever; but of course Mars in the story is inhabited, by people whom the male protagonist, Duncan Weaver, despises - to his cost.
2026 April 29th:
ECCENTRIC OLD TOMES
Ace researcher Lone Wolf has uncovered a trove of occultist material which we OSS fans might put to our own uses, in the business of recruiting further accretions to our cherished world-gestalts. Here, then, are three passages to read (or skim-read if, as with me, your tolerance of New-Agey waffle is low), from writers describing weird evolutionary sequences which put me in mind of ERB's Caprona - The Land That Time Forgot. From our perspective the old occultists might be said to have built better than they knew (and after all, isn't that also true of many mainstream classic SF authors? They didn't know what they were really doing. Otherwise they would have done more of it).
[1] From Annie Besant's Theosophy (1912):
...a series of six globes composed of the matter of the spheres of varying densities is formed in connection with each planet — seven globes, including the planet. Such a series is called a Chain, and during its period of evolution it passes through seven stages, or lives ; there is thus a succession of seven Chains, and this complete series is termed a Scheme of Evolution, and is under the charge of a mighty spiritual Intelligence, called by Theosophists a ‘‘Ruler of seven Chains”. There are ten of these in our Solar System, but only seven are in manifestation, ruled by the “seven Spirits before the throne of God”, mentioned in the “Revelation of S. John”. They are at different stages of evolution, marked' by the sphere of matter in which their lowest, globes exist. Thus the Neptunian and the Terrene Chains have each three globes in the physical sphere, for these are both at their deepest point of descent into matter, in their middle, or fourth, life. The seven globes of the Earth Chain include Mars, the Earth, and Mercury; those of the Neptunian, Neptune and his two satellites.
https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.274520/page/n82/mode/1up
[2] From L. P. Gratacap, The Certainty of a Future Life in Mars, Being the Posthumous Papers of Bradford Torrey Dodd edited by L. P. Gratacap (1903):
My father had an interesting habit of snapping his fingers on both hands together over his head when he declaimed in this way, always circling about the room in a rapid stride. I remember he stopped in front of me and continued in a strain something like this:
"For myself I am convinced that there has been an evolution in the order of beings from one planet to another, that there is going on a stream of transference, from one plane of life here to planes elsewhere, and that the stream is pouring in as well as out of this world, and that it may be, in our case, pouring both ways, that is, we may be losing individuals into lower grades of life as well as emitting them to higher. See, what economy!
"Instead of wasting the energies of imagination to account for the destinations of millions upon millions of human beings, the countless host that has occupied the surfaces of this earth through all the historic and prehistoric ages, we can, upon this assumption, reduce the number of individuals immensely, allowing that spirits are constantly arriving, constantly departing, and that the sum total in the solar system remains perhaps nearly fixed, just as in the electrolysis of water we have hydrogen rising at one electrode and oxygen at the other by transmission of atoms of hydrogen and atoms of oxygen toward each electrode through the water itself, in opposite directions, while for a sensible time the mass of water remains unchanged.
"Let us suppose that in Mercury some form of mental life exists, that it is individualized, that it expresses the physical constants of that globe, that its mentality has reached the point where it can make use of the resources of Mercury, can respond to its physical constants so far as they awaken poetry or art or religion or science. Suppose that this life is one of extreme forcefulness, of stress and storm, like some prehistoric condition on our globe, but invested with more intellectual attributes than the same ages on our earth required or possessed, perhaps reaching a permanent condition not unlike that depicted in the Niebelungen Lied or the Sagas of the North. It might be called the brawn period. Then the spirits born upon our planet or on any other planet in an identical condition, would find after death their destination in Mercury, where they could evolve up to the point where they might return to as, or to some other planet fitted for a higher life.
"Then Venus, we may imagine, succeeding Mercury, carries a higher type, an emotional life, though of course I am not influenced by her accidental name, in suggesting it. Here in Venus, a period perchance resembling a mixture of the pagan Grecian life and the troubadour life of Provence may prevail and again to it have flown the spirits which in our planet only touch that development, which from Venus flow to us, those adapted for the religious or intellectual phase we present. This Venus life might be called the sense period.
"And now our world follows, with its scientific life which probably represents its normal limit. Beyond this it will not go. As we have developed through a brawn and sense period to our present stage, so in Mercury and Venus, ages have prevailed of development which eventuated in their final fixed stages at brawn and sense. In Venus, too, the brawn stage preceded the sense period. In us both have preceded the scientific stage. There has been, may we not think, constant interchanges between these planets of such lives as survive material dissolution, and they have found the nidus that fits them in each. Souls leaving us in a brawn epoch have fled to Mercury, souls leaving us in a sense epoch have fled to Venus, and all souls in Mercury or Venus, ready for reincarnation in a scientific epoch, have come to us.
"But there is an important postulate underlying this theory. It is, that upon each planet the possibilities of development just attain to the margin of the next higher step in mental evolution. That is, that on Mercury the period of brawn develops to the possibility of the period of sense without fully exemplifying it, so in Venus the period of sense develops to the possibility of the period of science without attaining it, and in our world the period of science develops to the period of spirit, without, in any universal way, exhibiting it.
"These are steps progressively represented, I may imagine, in the planets. And, in the further progress outward, we reach the planet Mars. Let us place here the period of spirit. On Mars is accomplished in society, and accompanied by an accomplishment in its physical features, also, of those ideals of living which the great and good unceasingly labor to secure for us here and unceasingly fail to secure. O my child, if we could learn somehow to get tidings from that distant sphere, if only the viewless abyss of space between our world and Mars might be bridged by the noiseless and unseen waves of a magnetic current."
[3] From Aleister
Crowley, Liber LI. The Lost Continent:
It was the most ancient tradition of the Atlantean Magicians that they were the survivors of a race inhabiting a country called Lemuria, of which the South Pacific archipelago may be the remains. These Lemurians had, they held, built up a civilization equal, if not superior to their own; but through a misunderstanding of magical law — some said the 2nd, some the 8th, some the 23rd — had involved themselves and their land in ruin. Others thought that the Lemurians had succeeded in their magical task, and broken their temple. In any case, it was the secret Lemurian tradition that they themselves represented the survivals of a yet earlier race who lived on ice, and they of yet another who lived in fire, and they again of earlier colonists from Mars. The theory, in fine, was that the aim of man is to attain the Sun, whence, according to one school of cosmology, he was exiled in the cosmic catastrophe which resulted in the formation of Neptune. His task on any given planet was therefore to overturn the laws of Nature on that planet, thus mastering it sufficiently to enable him to make the leap to the next planet inward. Exactly how and in what sense the leap was made remains obscure, even to the heirs of Atlantis.
Lone Wolf adds:
...not sure whether Crowley actually believed all this or
whether it was just an invented background detail of his curious
“novel”.
The next logical step was the “attaining of Venus”, as Crowley
designates the spiritual goal of the Atlanteans to which were
dedicated all the efforts of their civilization ending with the
artificially induced destruction of their islands, that probably was
the way of mass transmigration to the that next planet. But it is
curious that in this excerpt he says “colonists from Mars” for
the original humans who came to Earth as if speaking about a physical
travel and not just interplanetary reincarnation.
Comment from Zendexor:
"Attaining
the Sun" sounds interesting. Maybe as disembodied spirits who don't
mind the heat, or as neutronium-bodied Solarians (vide Hal Clement's Proof)?
2026 April 26th:
LUCKY GUESSES ABOUT MOONS
Many
of you have doubtless heard of Jonathan Swift's amazing fictional idea,
way back in the early eighteenth century, that Mars has two moons -
amazing because it turned out to be true when Phobos and Deimos were
discovered in 1877.
Today in an email from Lone Wolf I learn of a
similar "lucky guess". Apparently the theosophist, Annie Besant,
asserted back in 1912 that Neptune had two moons. This was many years
before the discovery in 1949 of Neptune's actual second satellite,
Nereid.
In my view Besant's "clairvoyance" is less amazing than
Swift's, because Voyager 2 went on to discover six more Neptunian moons,
putting an end to the period in which the known Neptunian total stood
at two, whereas Mars' total of two hasn't changed and so even today
reflects what was said in Gulliver's Travels.
Nevertheless, the 1912 assertion about the Neptune system is startling;
perhaps especially for an oldster like me, who remembers having learned
about the Solar System from texts that were printed long before
Voyager. What value, if any, can we ascribe to such guesses?
My view inclines towards that of Lone Wolf, who in the same email remarked:
....Scientists, of course, would have dismissed the topic as fabrication or coincidence and even the believers in theosophy today don't take those old writings of Leadbeater and Besant seriously knowing the astronomical facts in them to be untrue; they try to sweep them under the rug as unorthodox deviations from the doctrine by quoting their denouncing by H. P. Blavatsky as “misunderstanding of the statements in some of the messages of the Mahatmas”. But those are not just theoretical speculations they write about, but visions reported as results of “clairvoyant research”. How then came they into being in the first place? I think even fantasies and fabrications should have some explanation and not be excluded from study just because of their apparent “unreality”. The psychological theories of C. G. Jung about the collective unconscious and its archetypes in his study of myths and symbols was probably the first step and our speculations about the alternative realities contained in the noosphere could probably get us further in that direction.
Anyhow, one is tempted to add the wish that Miss Besant was right when she said that "Neptune and his two satellites" were habitable!
2026 April 17th:
INVENTING NAMES: THE ORIGIN OF MURASH MONN
It happened like this (about a week ago).
Background: my wife and I share the household tasks as follows: she
sees to the dusting, ironing, hoovering and gardening, and the keeping of accounts,
all of them actions she wishes done to a high
standard; I take care of the stuff that a moron could do - loading and
unloading of the dishwasher and washing machines, hanging out
clothes to dry and taking them in, and the regular daily shopping.
It
happened that she asked if the next clothes-wash could be a
"lights-wash" - a lot of her things are light in colour. So I made a
note to remind myself to do a Mary-wash on Monday:
"M-wash Mon."
My handwrighting is usually quite clear, as I'm finicky about it, but this time "M-wash" came out looking like "Murash".
Never let such a chance go to waste!
Murash Monn now joins the crowd of names waiting to be attached to people on the planet Ooranye.
2026 April 15th:
CAN A CREATIVE FOCUS ENLARGE THE REAL?
Further email correspondence with researcher Lone Wolf, concerning
material he sent to me about the claims to knowledge of life on our
neighbouring worlds asserted by Charles Leadbeater in The Inner Life
(1911), leads me to follow on from my previous Diary entry, Migration to Mercury.
In that entry a week ago I remarked on
the mystery of how the heck did this Leadbeater fellow, and
others of his sort, get to be so certain about their claims.
After all, it's one thing to let one's imagination rip in writing OSS
fiction; it's quite something else to assert it as fact!
In my view it would be facile to dismiss these theosophists as liars. The Inner Life
doesn't have the ring of deliberate falsehood; it's hard to read that
sort of stuff without concluding that the author believed what he was
saying. (I get the same impression and the same problem from current New Agey stuff about
channelling Atlantis, etc.)
I mentioned
this quandary to Lone Wolf.
His reply has really and truly got me thinking:
Might creative ideas, as he suggests, clump together to form a collective memory
which overspreads the boundary between subjective and objective, to enlarge the domain of
what counts as real?
Might the "reality engineering" theme I use in Uranian Thule become, some day, true?
Here are Lone Wolf's words (I've put the central point in bold) plus an earlier email in which he provides an online link to the 1911 book:
[email, 12 April 2026]
I've been wondering about the same thing. It doesn't seem to me that this could have been a deliberate hoax – I mean that Leadbeater probably believed himself in what he was writing about Mars, otherwise why would he jeopardize the credibility of all the other things in his book? And it could be easily seen by anyone who has read the novel of Percy Greg [Across the Zodiac (1880)] that he simply summarizes his description of the Martians (up to their appearance, clothes, houses of coloured glass, artificial language, speech-recording machines, electrical technology, autocratic social structure, materialistic beliefs and secret occult order, etc.), but only putting them within a more modern (for his time) astronomical depiction of the planet – that of a Lowell-type Mars. That's why I was speculating that he has read that novel too and maybe even forgotten it, but the images from it have emerged from his subconscious mind into his visions. I don't know what kind of procedure the theosophists have used for their “astral projections”, but I guess it was something that induces a self-hypnotic trance like lucid dream or shamanic experience. In such state the smallest suggestion could serve as a seed for the creation of a whole imaginary world, maybe even maintained independently from the individual brain in the collective subconscious where other persons could experience it too and thus confirm it as “real” (I've read descriptions of such rituals among the primitive tribes in which a shaman could supposedly share his experience in a state of collective trance and take the whole group of participants in his visionary quests to the invisible worlds of the spirits). Hence came my hypothesis about the cosmic memory of the planetary noosphere, in which all mental experiences, including phantasies and dreams, are collected, maintained and even developed by an active collective subconscious. Thus all fantastic worlds from the novels could exist “objectively” out there and they could be experienced not only in imagination, but first hand, as “real”, if only one can “tune” his mind and perceptions to them. Then if we add to this the modern ideas about multiverse and parallel realities, the very notion of “reality” may become relative and one can wonder whether there is actual difference between the creative imagination of a writer and the “channelling” of a psychic medium. Maybe then the difference between reality and imagination, the external sensual experience and the internal mental experience, is just a matter of habitual focus of the conscious mind (but acquired on a subconscious level!) upon this or that possible world, unconditionally and unconsciously accepting the basic premises which define it. If we could learn how to change this by will we would probably be able to wander to different possible worlds, becoming a kind of “psychonauts” and a whole new science of “psychonautics” could be developed.
As for the idea about migration and reincarnation to other planets, I first thought it was rather extravagant, but it turned out that it was quite popular once among the spiritist and spiritualist circles a century or so ago, as I learned from the book of Theodor Flournoy about the Swiss medium Madame Helene Smith (who supposedly communicated with a person reincarnated on Mars and also produced descriptions and paintings of the Martian life and even texts in Martian language and its scripture). There seems to have been different theories among the spiritualists, some of them used also in the fantastic literature, about that to which planets we would go and from where we may have come. I know that Lovecraft was familiar with the theosophist writings and maybe therefrom he took that notion about Mercury as a future abode of life. I remember also Aleister Crowley writing in his rather obscure book The Lost Continent (which was supposed to be something like a satirical fantastic novel) that the ancient Atlanteans inherited from their Lemurian ancestors the belief that life goes from planet to planet starting from Neptune in direction to the Sun, from where once it was exiled, thus coming to Earth from Mars, while the next immediate spiritual goal being Venus. But then there is the opposite opinion expressed in the book Melbourne and Mars (1889) by Joseph Frazer (about each I have written once before, I think) – he describes an utopian society on Mars, where more evolved souls incarnate, including such from Earth, while those who have not yet reached that state, but are more developed than the other Earthlings, could be living on both planets in different bodies simultaneously, as do the protagonist of that novel. Then I also came across another book by some author from New Zealand (L.P. Gratacap, The Certainty of a Future Life in Mars, 1903), who develops a whole theory about the souls evolving while incarnating consecutively from planet to planet in direction away from the Sun – thus, if I remember correctly, according to him Mercury was a place of physical development, Venus – of aesthetical, Earth – of rational and Mars – of spiritual...
[Note re Mars and link to theosophist text in previous email from Lone Wolf, 7th April 2026:]
I finally found again that text of Charles Leadbeater, in which he describes his “clairvoyant research” of the planet Mars and its inhabitants – it was in Vol. II of his book The Inner Life from the 1911 edition:
https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.152110/page/n409/mode/1up
I read it during my first university studies back in the 1980s... The description of the Martian civilization, culture and society is like a resume of that in Percy Greg's book Across the Zodiac (1880). The only thing that Leadbeater adds is the notion of the canals (in Greg's book there are no canals yet, but the old Mars with open seas and continents from the Dawes-Proctor's maps)... Obviously according to Leadbeater Mars and Mercury are part of the so-called “planetary chain” of the Earth, as in theosophy is called the circle of seven planets through which the “wave of life” (a great multitude of monads reincarnating en masse) passes consecutively in its evolution over enormous periods of time. Thus Mars has been before Earth the abode of our transmigrating souls in some very distant past, while the Mercury should be such in the future, when the Earth will no longer be inhabitable, passing itself into “obscuration”. Later though, Madame H.P. Blavatsky criticized this notion calling it a misconception – according to her the physical planets are each one the middle, visible members of their respective planetary chains, while the other six members (3 on the descending and 3 on the ascending arc) are located on the subtler planes of existence (astral, mental and causal), thus being invisible. So this chapter of Leadbeater's book was removed from its later editions.
2026 April 8th:
MIGRATION TO MERCURY
To start with, I shall quote from H P Lovecraft's The Shadow Out of Time
some unforgettable lines about the mind-swapping Great Race: alien
intelligences who had been on our world for a long age - from about a
billion to about fifty million years before our present day.
Originating on a distant, fantastically ancient, dying planet, they arrived here when they "sent their minds en masse into that future
race best adapted to house them - the con-shaped things that peopled
our earth a billion years ago. Thus the Great Race came to be, while
the myriad minds sent backward were left to die in the horror of strange
shapes."
Stid: Charming. The rotters.
Zendexor:
And the ruthlessness is all the more effective in that Lovecraft
doesn't bother to stress it - he has so much else to say, including
stuff about a far nastier species which manages to terrify even the Great Race.
These adversaries of the G.R. are semi-polypous, semi-material horrors
who have been banished underground and sealed off with trap doors...
Thus the reader is drawn ever deeper through zone upon zone of cosmic
spine-chill.
But back to the Great Race - in its cone-shaped
form it was "of a queer and intricate shape resembling no life-form
known to science, which had lived till only fifty million years before
the advent of man".
Stid: I see: that terminal date of about 50,000,000 years before the present, together with the billion-year-old arrival, brackets the continuous career of the Great Race on our planet. Except that they will come back, won't they?
Zendexor: Not while we're around, but later, yes, they will reappear:
...After man there would be the mighty beetle civilization, the bodies of whose members the cream of the Great Race would seize when the monstrous doom overtook the elder world (i.e. when the polypous things burst out from their confinement).
Stid: Again, rather selfish, to scarper and let the beetle-things cope with the polypous break-out.
Zendexor: Well, that's life, Stid; at any rate in the HPL universe, it's horror eat horror. Though in this case I'd say there must surely have been an
interval before the beetle-intelligences evolved. In all that
time, the polypous horrors were slowly weakening; after all, the one
the narrator meets on that night in Australia was already less than
lethal, and by the time of the beetle folk they were most likely quite
dormant, more or less.
Anyway, let me get on to the point of this essay. After the beetle civilization:
...Later, as the earth's span closed, the transferred minds would again migrate through time and space - to another stopping-place in the bodies of the bulbous vegetable entities of Mercury.
Stid: And that's it? No more migrations by the Great Race?
Zendexor: No further escapes are mentioned in the story.
Stid: Looks like the other races in the Galaxy will be able to breathe easily after that, then.
Zendexor: Yes, Mercury will be the end of the line for the Great Race. And that theme is echoed in another work - a greatly different one - to which I've just been alerted by Lone Wolf, the weekly contributor to Guess The World and a great researcher into the byways of OSS literature. The author is a theosophist, Charles Leadbeater, and using the link Lone Wolf sent me I quote from page 424 of volume II of The Inner Life (1911 edition):
Of our future home, Mercury, we know much less than of Mars, for visits
to it have been hurried and infrequent. Many people would think it
incredible that life such as ours could exist on Mercury, under a sun
that appears at least seven times as large as it does here. The heat,
however, is not at all so intense as would be supposed. I am informed
that this is due to the presence of a layer of gas on the outskirts of
the Mercurian atmosphere, which prevents most of the heat from
penetrating. We are told also that the most destructive of all possible
storms on Mercury is one which even for a moment disturbs the stability
of this gaseous envelope. When that happens a kind of whirl-pool is set
up in it, and for a moment a shaft of direct sunlight comes from the sun
through its vortex. Such a shaft instantly destroys whatever life comes
in its way, and burns up in a moment everything combustible.
Fortunately such storms are rare. The inhabitants whom I have seen there
are much like ourselves, though again somewhat smaller.
The influence of gravity both on Mars and Mercury is less than half what
it is on earth, but while on Mars I did not notice any particular way
in which advantage had been taken of this, I observed on Mercury that
the doors of the houses were quite a considerable height from the
ground, needing what for us would be a respectable gymnastic feat to
reach them, though on Mercury it is only a light spring that is
required. All the inhabitants of that planet are from birth possessed of
etheric sight; I remember that the fact was first brought to my notice
by observing a child who was watching the movements of some crawling
creature; and I saw that when it entered its abode he was still able to
follow its movements, even when it was deep down under the ground...
Stid: Was this supposed to be fiction?
Zendexor:
Not supposed to be, no! But it was all made up - as we now know,
more's the pity! It would be interesting to know whence the
theosophists acquired their convictions of certainty. [See the following Diary entry, Can a creative focus enlarge the real?]
Anyhow,
what I'm leading up to, is that with the thematic overlap of Lovecraft and Leadbeater we
seem to be acquiring an accretion of the idea of Mercury as the future
home of Man. All we need now is a third angle on the theme and it will
really take off. It's an idea that should occur naturally, after all,
to those who assume the Sun is getting cooler and cooler - a reasonable
idea, though scientists now think the opposite is true.
2026 March 18th:
MAGAZINE VS. BOOK
Researcher/contributor Lone Wolf remarked to me in an email of15 March:
Maybe this is just a personal taste of mine, but I've noticed that when some novel or novelette from the pulp era is adapted and published as a book later, I usually prefer the original magazine version better, like for instance Leigh Brackett's stories featuring Eric John Stark. This is especially so with her second Martian story of this series - Black Amazon of Mars, with its quasi-Lovecraftian Ice Creatures, which in the book version are replaced with just some lost Martian tribe living out of phase with physical reality, if I remember correctly (something so much less interesting that I even don't remember all the details). The indirect allusion to a native life on Phobos is also removed from the text - here's the comparison of the same sentence from the two versions:
But the Martian had fought beside him through a long guerrilla campaign among the harried tribes of the nearer moon. (Black Amazon of Mars, Planet Stories, March 1951)
But the Martian had fought beside him through a long guerrilla campaign far to the south, among the harried tribes of the Dryland borders. (People of the Talisman, 1962)
I don't think this is due only to the need to adapt the settings in accord with the progress of astronomical knowledge (it's still the OSS period and the possibility of life on small moons and asteroids was scientifically speaking highly improbable even in that era), but it's just that in pulp SF there reigned that carefree attitude in which anything goes so long as it is made to seem probable and makes a good story. I think this type of literature functioned as a kind of folklore of the scientific era and the pulp magazines with their community of readers were like an equivalent of the city taverns and similar places in olden times, where fantastic highly exaggerated stories of sailors and travellers could be heard and so legends were born (like the stories about Ulysses, Sindbad, etc.). Their charm perhaps comes precisely from their obvious improbability, just like the tales of Baron Munchhausen.
Zendexor: LW is, I'm sure, on to something here, and his remarks make me want to read Black Amazon of Mars.
However, I have never regarded the strange northern Martians in People of the Talisman as "just some lost Martian tribe", i.e. like the rest of the human COMOLD bunch. To me they have always been non-human "real Martians". Partly perhaps that's due to the illustration on the cover of my Ace books edition! But also, this view of them is supported (in my view) by their first appearance in the text:

...five figures had appeared in the street. ...They were very tall, these figures, towering over the people of Kushat, towering even over Stark, but they were excessively slender and they moved with swaying motion like reeds before the wind... queer tall caps...exaggerated their elongated narrow skulls... a structure of facial bones that seemed to be all brow and jaw with little in between but two great round eyes like dark moons...
That decided the issue for me on first reading and ever since.
Stid: But perhaps you were hasty in shutting off your attention from this issue after that one first impression. One could argue to a different conclusion from a passage a few pages further on:
...Thanis said furiously, "Ban Cruach would never have promised his help to these monsters."
"That was a long time ago," Stark said. "I doubt that they were monsters then..."
Given a modicum of ingenuity you could interpret this as a hint that the oddities of these elongated people are the result of age-long evolution away from the human norm, which means they could still count as a basically human tribe, isolated rather than alien.
Zendexor: I could indeed argue thus, but I would not. That's not to deny that your citation is worth thinking about; but one must assess the total effect of Brackett's depiction of the folk who live beyond the "Gates of Death", her portrayal of their mentality, and the way they move, and the spooky part they play in the story; and at the end of it all I come back to saying that they are real non-human Martians.
One last point: it's certainly interesting to learn that in the original tale Phobos was imagined as sufficiently ample to contain "harried tribes"! Very carefree writing, as LW points out. Any chance of justifying the idea logically? Using one's excuse-making power at full strength one might envisage a special short-range gravitational force (an idea I've used in some of my own stories) which operates only close to the surface of small worlds, undetectable at greater distances, and thus resulting in cases of surprising habitability...
That would help explain conditions on the asteroid Iskar.
2020 March 6th:

WINTER BLUES ON SATURN
On page 35 of the Astronomy Now publication, Saturn: Exploring the Ringed Planet (2015), is a picture with the caption:
Winter is coming. Taken by Cassini on 29 July 2013, this view of Saturn shows the planet's southern polar region, growing blue as winter approaches and temperatures plunge to -172 degrees Celsius, while the north enjoys summer, such as it is...
I tried scanning it but the colours don't come out at all well. I found a better one online, and have posted it here. You can see the contrasting seasonal colours in the two hemispheres.
Now, this to me is a striking example of a possible "OSS echo". It's
almost inviting an author to write a tale of the Captain Future variety
in which a habitable Saturn has cloud-tops which look bluer in winter!
It's as though poor old reality makes occasional halting steps towards an imitation of picturesque fiction. In my view it's worth keeping an eye out for such correspondences between the dreamlike and the actual, even if their relations with the real are as tenuous as they are here.
After all, we live in a rather retarded, special-needs solar system, and when, every now and then, it does seem to dodder in the right direction, we ought to show we appreciate the effort...
2026 February 28th:
DOWN WITH MISSION CONTROL
In a recent exchange of emails with the anomymous researcher "Lone Wolf" who contributes so many Guess The World scenes to this site, I found these remarks of his quite irresistible:
The “happy-go-lucky exploration”, as you call it, is my favourite type of those old time interplanetary adventure stories, especially when it is about secret inventions of private researchers, which made possible travels to other worlds of single individuals or at the most – small groups of private persons, that remain unknown or hidden from the general public (such as H.G. Wells' First Men in the Moon, G.P. Serviss' A Columbus of Space, G. Griffith's A Honeymoon in Space, C.S. Lewis' Out of the Silent Planet or J.W. Campbell's stories about Blake and Penton, etc.), – stories that are without fanfares and glory or pompous heroic stuff about expeditions seen and celebrated from all the world, not to mention such modern things like telemetry and other practices that expose the person to total monitoring by the “mission control”, deprive him of any privacy and make him more a machine or instrument than a man. That's why the old kind of secret adventures, which happen as if in a private world, have always had a special fascination for me...
Me too... though I also like the nostalgia of more public fictional enterprises in the old space program. And granted,
of course, that in real life the crew of Apollo 13 (to take the most
obvious example) had every reason to be grateful to Mission Control...
Of course, both in fiction and in real life, the
further from Earth people go, the less there can be a "mission
control" in any close or immediate sense - unless someone discovers a way to beat the light-speed in communications!
Another point in favour of adventure is the sheer number of possiblle
destinations. Even if the Solar System were to fall under a tyranny,
it's hard to believe that every landscape of every world and planetoid
could possibly be under regular surveillance. Even if everything could in principle be monitored, how could the monitors keep up?
2026 January 31st:
DARE-DEVIL WORLD-BUILDING
A
phrase which has stayed in my mind over the decades is, "a more
practical civilization". Not, you might think, a resonantly romantic or
adventurous idea. Yet it has impressed me for over half a century.
Here is the long sentence in which it occurs:
...During
the ages of hardships and incessant warring between their own various
races, as well as with the green men, and before they had fitted
themselves to the changed conditions, much of the high civilization and
many of the arts of the fair-haired Martians had become lost; but the
red race of today has reached a point where it feels that it has made up
in new discoveries and in a more practical civilization for all that
lies irretrievably buried with the ancient Barsoomians beneath the
countless intervening ages.
This excerpt from chapter XI of A Princess of Mars (note the magnificent sentence structure) might prompt the retort, "Are you sure, Mr Burroughs, that the modern culture of the red men of Barsoom
is all that practical? If they were practical wouldn't they have
surveyed their planet properly by now - they've had long enough in which
to do it - so that it wouldn't be left till recently to discover the
kaldanes, for example, or the Panars, or the secret valley of Kamtol?
And is it practical to have a political system which allows a jeddak
like Tul Axtar to rule untrammelled? And what about space travel - if
Gar Nal and Fal Sivas can both build spacecraft, why hasn't it caught on
before now?"
A fair enough demur, but it misses the point I'm aiming at. Still, first, regarding inconsistencies -
Edgar Rice Burroughs
wrote so much, I reckon it's a fair guess that he wrote at speed, and
without a lot of hesitation or planning. This meant some inconsistency
was bound to creep in, but, on the other hand, spontaneity had the good
effect that what poured up through the channel of his imagination was
allowed to flow free, without those rationalisations that can kill the
immediacy of the vision. (And of course it's a darned good thing, from the plotting point of view, that the Barsoomians hadn't carried out any exhaustive planetary surveys.)
A consequence of this ad hoc spontaneous approach was that the author could successfully take a risk without even knowing that he was doing
so, like a daredevil teenager showing off his bike-riding skills
instinctively for the sheer heck of it without even bothering to boast
"Look, no hands!" And this is where the "practical civilization" remark
comes in.
Barsoom, wonderfully, is not a decline-scenario,
despite the fact the world is slowing dying through the leakage of its
atmosphere. Burroughs, in making it clear that that the red men's
culture is healthily vibrant, confident and creative, is thus daring to forgo all the narrative advantages of (for example) the Brackett
Mars, which is culturally as well as physically on the wane. "Look, no
hands!" The equivalent here being, "Look, I can make my tale
picturesque without resorting to the autumnal tints of declinism!"
And the reward for dispensing with those autumn tints - which though pretty do tend to accumulate an atmosphere of gloom - is the creation of a unique version of sword-and-planet Mars: the only one, so far as I know, that so successfully embodies exuberant adventure.
2026 January 29th:
CONSPIRACIES GALORE
My mysterious pen-friend and anonymous researcher Lone Wolf has sent me links to a couple of tales by Ben Bova, a post-OSS author whom I haven't much read or enjoyed - I read one of his blockbusters and gave it back to the shop - but who evidently can delight me, as I hope these little gems delight you; here are links to them:
and
The Great Moon Hoax, or A Princess of Mars.
Playful explorations, these, of the theme which John Greer treated so successfully, and rather more seriously, in Out of the Chattering Planet
- namely, that the old ideas of an inhabited Solar System were true,
and that the modern probe results which seem to disprove them are
spurious.
Playful, yes, but lending a frisson of wonder to those readers who might in some circumstances be tempted to believe...
In Greer's version [spoiler alert], the deception is
carried out by the Martians themselves, who reverse-engineer the Terran
probes so as to transmit false data back to us. In the Bova versions, although the motive comes from the Martians the execution of the plot is
controlled by authorities on Earth, who agree that the Red Planet ought to
be left untouched for a while.
I would add that you could have another version of the conspiracy:
How about bringing in all the ludicrous claims that the Apollo
landings were faked? A story might be composed in which it's suggested that those who accuse the authorities of this cover-up are actually themselves conspiring: it is these private organizations, not governments, who are in league with the Martians who wish to
discredit Terran attempts at space travel. I suppose the reverse-engineering theme would have to be abandoned - but the Martians might be invisible, or something... I don't know; you work it out.
2026 January 24th:
A HANDY EXCUSE
Often have I stressed the point that OSS literature is full of "nods" to
science; perfunctory-but-essential references made in order to keep up
the bare, vital minimum suspension of disbelief. The "nods" are what
keeps "science fantasy" from being, simply, "fantasy". They are, in a
sense, incantations; they "cast the
spell of science" (paradoxical though this sounds) in the form of mood.
It's the mood that's convincing,
not the science, and yet - if psychology is a science, perhaps it is in
a way scientific after all!
Now, see if you can spot what struck me as the important "nod" in the following passage.
Something
in the very name of Pluto; something in the thought of this forlorn
ninth member of the Solar System took an irresistible hold upon his
imagination, and for days he seemed able to talk about little else.
“Think of this strange, strange world!” he would exclaim, while slowly
he would pace up and down the room and stroke his chin as though
weighing some momentous problem. “Think of it a billion miles or so
beyond Neptune, a globe perhaps no larger than the earth, lost in the
blackness of the outer void, its years longer than our centuries,
its seasons longer than our lives! What stories it would be able to
tell! Are there any living creatures there? Were any living beings ever
able to endure the terror of its sunless,
frozen
plains? Would we find the imprint of lost races upon its shores?—races
that flourished while the planet was heated from within, but that have
long ago fallen in the struggle with the cold?
“Just consider, Dan!—consider the scientific value of exploring such a
world. May not its geological strata hold the secret of evolution? yes,
the secret of the evolution of the universe? May we not, after
journeying there, be able to propound a new nebular hypothesis? May we
not even
have won the key to the Ultimate?”
- Stanton A Coblentz, Into Plutonian Depths (Wonder Stories Quarterly, Spring 1931)
You
saw it, didn't you? I'm sure you did: it's the handy assumption that
any frozen world enjoyed an early period when it was heated from within, and could
thus have been habitable.
Never mind the question, whether there
could have been enough time, way out at Pluto's distance, for life to
evolve while the planet had not yet completed its cooling. "Nods", that's to say OSS-style-scientific-mood-excuses, are immune to quantification.
That's how they work, and even reputedly hard-science-sf authors take advantage of the principle now and then. Consider the following couple of masterpieces, each a favourite of mine: Arthur C Clarke in The City and the Stars has Earth's last city, Diaspar, existing a billion years in the future, despite the scientific consensus that the Sun by that time will have heated up enough to make Earth uninhabitable (current thinking gives us only about 500 million years); and even more strikingly, Fred Hoyle in Fifth Planet has a star brighter than the Sun approach close to our Solar System in the year 2087, close enough for its planets to be reachable by interplanetary rocket, despite the obvious fact that such an intruder would have been spotted long before now as an already brilliant light in the sky.
In the case of Coblentz's theme, the pay-off is potentially immense.
Think of all those ice-worlds in the outer Solar System, now open to fictional exploitation by means of the "nod" in the above passage; think of the secrets they hold, or will hold once you fictioneers get going...
2026 January 20th:
THE POWER OF BLANK
Here's a riddle for you: what is the connection between Lancaster Castle and the fictional Solar System?
You may suspect that I'm just going to make the vague point that all big things are linked; that the sort of person who likes reading history will also have a big enough imagination to like to rove in the immensities of fictional space.
All that is true enough, but isn't quite what I have in mind to talk about today.
I'm serious about the riddle. Can you connect a medieval castle and the OSS?
Read on...
Today I attained the age of 72, and my wife Mary took
me out to our local historic town for an expenses-paid browse amongst Astronomy magazines and books, before our return home for a special meal. It's
always pleasant to visit Lancaster, only a few miles by train or bus
from our home in Heysham, and this time as we took the train we passed the Castle on our way from the station to the town centre.
Lancaster Castle is medieval, but lacks the drama of a violent medieval history (unless you count executions),
though later it was attacked more than once in the 1640s during the Civil War. Its record therefore doesn't match that of Carlisle Castle 66 miles to the north, which can boast of having
repelled an attack by Robert the Bruce in person in 1315. Mostly, I
suspect, Lancaster was too strong to acquire such renown; enemies took a look at it and decided not to bother...
Might we even conclude that a really impregnable, totally effective castle would have no history at all? It would keep the peace and protect the people, allowing authors to live in safe conditions where they could create their own histories...
And what about an empty-of-life Solar System? Need we grumble, as I
often do, about how it has failed to live up to fiction? Or -
Could we say that its blankness is all the more effective as an
imagination-trap, like fly-paper, attracting an infinity of ideas by that very barrenness which invites authors to fill it?